Content Options:

Add to favourites

View Options:

More Resources:

External link Handbook Publications

You are viewing the version of the document as on 2023-12-31.

Preamble

THE EUROPEAN COMMISSION,

Having regard to the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union,

Having regard to Regulation (EC) No 1060/2009 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 16 September 2009 on credit rating agencies, and in particular the third subparagraph of Article 21(4) and the third subparagraph of Article 21(4a) thereof,

Whereas:

  1. (1)

    Article 11a(1) of Regulation (EC) No 1060/2009 requires registered and certified credit rating agencies, when issuing a credit rating or a rating outlook, to submit rating information to the European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA). The requirement does not apply to ratings exclusively produced for and disclosed to investors for a fee. ESMA is required to publish the rating information submitted by the credit rating agencies on a public website called the European rating platform (ERP). Therefore, rules should be laid down regarding the content and the presentation of the information that credit rating agencies should make available to ESMA for the ERP.

  2. (2)

    In addition, Article 11(2) and Article 21(4)(e) of Regulation (EC) No 1060/2009 require credit rating agencies to submit information to ESMA on their historical performance data and for the purposes of ongoing supervision. The content and presentation of that information is laid down in Commission Delegated Regulation (EU) No 448/2012 and Commission Delegated Regulation (EU) No 446/2012, respectively. In order to allow for more efficient data processing by ESMA and simplification of data reporting for registered and certified credit rating agencies, integrated reporting requirements should be laid down for all the data that registered and certified credit rating agencies should report to ESMA. Therefore, this Regulation lays down rules regarding the data to be reported for the purpose of the ERP, the information to be made available on historical performance in the central repository established by ESMA, and the information that credit rating agencies should periodically report to ESMA for the purposes of ongoing supervision of credit rating agencies. This Regulation therefore repeals Delegated Regulation (EU) No 448/2012 and Delegated Regulation (EU) No 446/2012. ESMA should integrate all data reported by credit rating agencies for the ERP, the central repository and ongoing supervision of credit rating agencies into one ESMA database.

  3. (3)

    In order to ensure that the ERP provides up-to-date information on rating actions that are not exclusively disclosed to investors for a fee, it is necessary to describe the data to be reported, including the rating and outlook of the rated instrument or entity, the press releases accompanying rating actions, reports accompanying sovereign rating actions, type of rating action and date and hour of publication. Press releases, in particular, provide information on the key elements underlying the rating decision. The ERP provides rating users with a central access point to up-to-date rating information and lowers information costs by allowing for a global view of the different ratings issued on each rated entity or instrument.

  4. (4)

    In order to ensure a global view of all ratings assigned by different credit rating agencies on the same rated entity or instrument, credit rating agencies should use common identifiers for the rated entity and the rated instrument when reporting the rating data to ESMA. Therefore, for the identification of rated entities, issuers, originators and credit rating agencies, the only method of global unique identification should be the Global Legal Entity Identifier (LEI).

  5. (5)

    In order to ensure that the information on the ERP is up-to-date, rating information should be collected and published on a daily basis to allow for one daily update of the ERP outside Union business hours.

  6. (6)

    In order to allow ESMA to react promptly in the case of actual or potential non-compliance with Regulation (EC) No 1060/2009, the rating information reported by registered and certified credit rating agencies should enable ESMA to closely supervise the conduct and activities of credit rating agencies. Rating data should therefore be reported to ESMA on a monthly basis. However, in order to ensure proportionality, credit rating agencies that have fewer than 50 employees and that are not part of a group should be able to submit rating data every two months. ESMA should still be able to require those credit ratings agencies to carry out reporting on a monthly basis, in the light of the number and type of their ratings, including the complexity of the credit analysis, the relevance of the rated instruments or issuers, and the eligibility of the ratings to be used for regulatory purposes.

  7. (7)

    In order to avoid duplicated data reporting, ESMA should use for its ongoing supervision the data already reported for the purposes of the ERP. Credit rating agencies should also be required, for the purposes of ongoing supervision, to report information in respect of those credit ratings and rating outlooks not reported for the purposes of the ERP.

  8. (8)

    ESMA should use the data provided for the purposes of the ERP and for the purposes of its ongoing supervision to gather the information on the historical performance data that it should make available in the central repository in accordance with Article 11(2) of Regulation (EC) No 1060/2009. In order to further facilitate comparability and to ensure consistency with the data that has been reported in accordance with Delegated Regulation (EU) No 448/2012, newly certified credit rating agencies should be required to submit data regarding at least 10 years before their certification, or the period since the start of their activity. Certified credit rating agencies should not be required to report this data, partially or totally, where they can demonstrate that this would not be proportionate in view of their scale and complexity.

  9. (9)

    Credit rating agencies that are part of a group should be able to either report their ratings data separately to ESMA, or mandate one of the agencies within the group to submit the data on their behalf. However, due to credit rating agencies’ highly integrated organisation at Union level and in order to facilitate the understanding of the statistics, credit rating agencies are encouraged to report on a global basis for the whole group.

  10. (10)

    For the purposes of ESMA’s ongoing supervision and for the publication of the credit rating agencies’ historical performance reports, credit rating agencies may also, on a voluntary basis, report to ESMA credit ratings issued by third-country credit rating agencies belonging to the same group of credit rating agencies but not endorsed in accordance with Article 4(3) of Regulation (EC) No 1060/2009.

  11. (11)

    When submitting data, credit rating agencies should classify the credit ratings and rating outlooks issued in different categories: by rating type and sub-classifications, such as sector, industry or asset class, or by type of issuer and issue. Those categories are based on ESMA’s previous rating data collection experience and the need for supervision of credit rating data.

  12. (12)

    In order to provide for the reporting of credit ratings on new financial instruments that could arise as a result of financial innovation, a category should be included for reporting "other financial instruments". Moreover, the corporate ratings and the structured finance ratings categories should also have an "other" category to include all new types of corporate issues or structured finance instruments that cannot be classified into the existing categories.

  13. (13)

    In order to allow ESMA to establish the ERP and to allow for credit rating agencies to have sufficient time to adjust their internal systems to the new reporting requirements, credit rating agencies should submit a first report by 1 January 2016. In order to ensure comparability and continuity of data reported under this Regulation, the first report should contain data on all ratings issued and not withdrawn by 21 June 2015. In addition, the first report should contain data regarding credit ratings and rating outlooks issued by credit rating agencies from 21 June 2015 until 1 January 2016. The first report should contain the same type of data as the rating data to be submitted on a daily basis thereafter.

  14. (14)

    In order to allow ESMA to receive and process the data automatically in its internal systems, the data to be reported should be compiled in a standard format. Due to technical progress, a number of technical reporting instructions concerning the transmission or the format of the files to be submitted by credit rating agencies may have to be updated and communicated by ESMA through specific communications or guidelines.

  15. (15)

    This Regulation is based on the draft regulatory technical standards submitted by ESMA to the Commission in accordance with Article 10 of Regulation (EU) No 1095/2010 of the European Parliament and of the Council.

  16. (16)

    ESMA conducted an open public consultation on the draft regulatory technical standards on which this Regulation is based, analysed the potential related costs and benefits and requested the opinion of the Securities and Markets Stakeholder Group established in accordance with Article 37 of Regulation (EU) No 1095/2010.

  17. (17)

    In order to comply with Article 2(3) of Regulation (EU) No 462/2013 of the European Parliament and of the Council, this Regulation should apply from 21 June 2015,

HAS ADOPTED THIS REGULATION:

Article -1 Definitions

  1. (1)

    For the purposes of this Regulation the following definitions apply:

    1. (a)

      ‘Exit Day’ has the meaning given in the European Union (Withdrawal) Act 2018.

Article 1 Data to be reported

  1. (1)

    Credit rating agencies shall report data on all their issued or endorsed credit ratings or rating outlooks in accordance with Articles 8, 9, and 11. Credit rating agencies shall report all credit ratings and rating outlooks issued at rated entity level and on all their issued debt instruments, where applicable.

  2. (2)

    Credit rating agencies shall ensure the accuracy, completeness and availability of the data reported to the Financial Conduct Authority (“FCA”) and shall ensure that reports are submitted in accordance with Articles 8, 9 and 11 using appropriate systems developed on the basis of technical instructions provided by the FCA.

  3. (3)

    Credit rating agencies shall notify the FCA immediately of any exceptional circumstances that may temporarily prevent or delay their reporting in accordance with this Regulation.

  4. (4)

    For groups of credit rating agencies, the members of each group may mandate one member to submit reports required under this Regulation on their behalf. Each credit rating agency on whose behalf such a report is submitted shall be identified in the data submitted to the FCA.

  5. (5)

    For the purposes of Article 11(2) and Article 21(4)(e) of Regulation (EC) No 1060/2009, a credit rating agency reporting on behalf of a group may include data on credit ratings and rating outlooks issued by third-country credit rating agencies belonging to the same group and not endorsed. Where a credit rating agency does not report such data it shall give an explanation in its qualitative data report, in Fields 9 and 10 of Table 1 of Part 1 of Annex I to this Regulation.

  6. (6)

    Credit rating agencies shall disclose the solicitation status of each reported credit rating or rating outlook by specifying whether it is unsolicited with participation or unsolicited without participation in accordance with Article 10(5) of Regulation (EC) No 1060/2009 or solicited.

Article 2 Reporting of default status and withdrawals

  1. (1)

    A credit rating agency shall report a default in respect of a rating in Fields 6 and 13 of Table 2 of Part 2 of Annex I where one of the following events has occurred:

    1. (a)

      the rating indicates that a default has occurred according to the credit rating agency’s definition of default;

    2. (b)

      the rating has been withdrawn due to insolvency of the rated entity or due to debt restructuring;

    3. (c)

      any other instance in which the credit rating agency considers a rated entity or rated instrument as defaulted, materially impaired or equivalent.

  2. (2)

    Where a reported rating is withdrawn, the reason for that shall be reported in Field 11 of Table 2 of Part 2 of Annex I.

Article 3 Rating types

Credit rating agencies shall, when reporting credit ratings or rating outlooks, classify them as one of the following types of ratings:

  1. (a)

    corporate ratings;

  2. (b)

    structured finance ratings;

  3. (c)

    sovereign and public finance ratings;

  4. (d)

    other financial instruments.

Article 4 Corporate ratings

  1. (1)

    Credit rating agencies shall, when reporting corporate ratings, classify them within one of the following industry segments:

    1. (a)

      financial institutions, including banks, brokers and dealers;

    2. (b)

      insurance;

    3. (c)

      all other corporate entities or issuers which are not included in points (a) and (b).

  2. (2)

    Credit rating agencies shall classify corporate issues as one of the following issue types:

    1. (a)

      bonds;

    2. (b)

      CRR covered bonds as defined in point 128A of Article 4(1) of Regulation (EU) No 575/2013 that meet the eligibility requirements set out in paragraphs 1 to 3, 6 and 7 of Article 129 of that Regulation;

    3. (c)

      other types of covered bonds, for which the credit rating agency has used specific covered bond methodologies, models or key rating assumptions for issuing the credit rating and which are not included in point (b);

    4. (d)

      other types of corporate issues which are not included in points (a), (b) and (c).

  3. (3)

    The country code of a rated entity or its issues in Field 10 of Table 1 of Part 2 of Annex I shall be that of the country of domicile of the entity.

Article 5 Structured finance ratings

  1. (1)

    Structured finance ratings shall relate to a financial instrument or other assets resulting from a securitisation transaction or scheme referred to in

    point 1 of Article 2 of Regulation 2017/2402/EU.

  2. (2)

    Credit rating agencies shall, when reporting structured finance ratings, classify them within one of the following asset classes:

    1. (a)

      asset-backed securities, including auto loans, boat loans, airplane loans, student loans, consumer loans, small and medium-sized enterprise loans, healthcare loans, manufactured housing loans, film loans, utility loans, equipment leases, credit card receivables, tax liens, non-performing loans, recreational vehicle loans, leases to individuals, leases to businesses, and trade receivables;

    2. (b)

      residential mortgage-backed securities, including prime and non-prime residential mortgage-backed securities, and home equity loans;

    3. (c)

      commercial mortgage-backed securities, including retail or office property loans, hospital loans, care residences loans, storage facilities loans, hotel loans, nursing facilities loans, industrial loans, and multifamily properties loans;

    4. (d)

      collateralised debt obligations, including collateralised loan obligations, credit-backed obligations, collateralised synthetic obligations, single-tranche collateralised debt obligations, credit fund obligations, collateralised debt obligations of asset-backed securities, and collateralised debt obligations of collateralised debt obligations;

    5. (e)

      asset-backed commercial papers;

    6. (f)

      other securitisation instruments which are not included in points (a) to (e), including structured covered bonds, structured investment vehicles, insurance-linked securities and derivative product companies.

  3. (3)

    Where applicable, a credit rating agency shall also indicate which specific sub-asset class each rated instrument belongs to in Field 34 of Table 1 of Part 2 of Annex I.

  4. (4)

    The country code of securitisation instruments shall be reported in Field 10 of Table 1 of Part 2 of Annex I and shall be that of the country of domicile of the majority of the underlying assets. Where it is not possible to identify the country of domicile of the majority of the underlying assets, the rated instrument shall be classified as "international".

Article 6 Sovereign and public finance ratings

  1. (1)

    Credit rating agencies shall, when reporting data concerning ratings of sovereign and public entities and of supranational organisations and their issued debt, classify them within one of the following sectors:

    1. (a)

      State, where the rated entity is a State or the issuer of the rated debt or financial obligation, debt security or other financial instrument is a State, or a special purpose vehicle of a State, as referred to in point (v)(i) and (ii) of Article 3(1) of Regulation (EC) No 1060/2009 and where the rating refers to a State;

    2. (b)

      regional or local authority, where the rated entity is a regional or local authority or the issuer of the rated debt or financial obligation, debt security or other financial instrument is a regional or local authority, or a special purpose vehicle of a regional or local authority, as referred to in point (v)(i) and (ii) of Article 3(1) of Regulation (EC) No 1060/2009 and where the rating refers to a regional or a local authority;

    3. (c)

      international financial institution, as referred to in point (v)(iii) of Article 3(1) of Regulation (EC) No 1060/2009;

    4. (d)

      supranational organisation, such as those institutions which are not included in point (c) and that are established, owned and controlled by more than one sovereign government shareholder, including organisations referred to in Section U of Annex I to Regulation (EC) No 1893/2006 of the European Parliament and of the Council;

    5. (e)

      public entities, including those referred to in Sections O, P and Q of Annex I to Regulation (EC) No 1893/2006.

  2. (2)

    Where no specific country can be identified as the country of issuance in the case of international financial institutions or supranational organisations as specified in paragraph (1)(c) and (d), the rated issuer shall be classified as "international" in Field 10 of Table 1 of Part 2 of Annex I.

Article 7 Other financial instruments

Credit ratings or rating outlooks issued on a financial instrument as defined in Article 3(1)(k) of Regulation (EC) No 1060/2009 that cannot be classified as corporate issues under Article 4(2) of this Regulation, as structured finance instruments under Article 5 of this Regulation or as sovereign and public entity issues under Article 6 of this Regulation, shall be reported under the other financial instruments category.

Article 8 Reporting for the purpose of publication on the public rating database

  1. (1)

    Credit rating agencies shall report data on all credit ratings or rating outlooks pursuant to Article 11a(1) of Regulation (EC) No 1060/2009 each time it issues or endorses a credit rating or a rating outlook that is not exclusively disclosed to investors for a fee.

  2. (2)

    Credit ratings and rating outlooks referred to in paragraph 1, issued between 20:00:00 Central European Time (CET) on one day and 19:59:59 CET on the following day shall be reported until 21:59:59 CET on the following day.

  3. (3)

    For each credit rating or rating outlook reported in accordance with paragraph 1, the accompanying press release referred to in point 5 of Part I of Section D of Annex I to Regulation (EC) No 1060/2009 shall be reported at the same time. Where that press release is firstly issued and submitted in a language other than English, an English version may also be submitted where and at the time that it becomes available.

  4. (4)

    For the ratings referred to in points (a), (b) and (c) of Article 6(1), the accompanying research report referred to in point 1 of Part III of Section D of Annex I to Regulation (EC) No 1060/2009 shall be reported. Where that research report is firstly issued and submitted in a language other than English, an English version may also be submitted where and at the time that it becomes available.

Article 9 Reporting for the purpose of the FCA supervision

  1. (1)

    As referred to in Article 21(4)(e) of Regulation (EC) No 1060/2009, credit rating agencies shall report data on all credit ratings and rating outlooks issued or endorsed, or issued in a third country and not endorsed as referred to in Article 1(5), including information on all entities or debt instruments submitted for their initial review or for preliminary rating, as referred to in point 6 of Part I of Section D of Annex I to Regulation (EC) No 1060/2009.

  2. (2)

    For those credit ratings and rating outlooks to which Article 8 does not apply, credit rating agencies shall report rating data relating to the preceding calendar month on a monthly basis.

  3. (3)

    A credit rating agency that has fewer than 50 employees and that is not part of a group of credit rating agencies may provide the rating data referred to in paragraph 2 every two months, unless the FCA requires monthly reporting in view of the nature, complexity and range of issues of its credit ratings. That rating data shall refer to the preceding two calendar months.

  4. (4)

    The rating data referred to in paragraph 2 shall be submitted to the FCA within 15 days from the end of the period that is covered by the report. Where the 15th day of the month falls on a public holiday in the country of domicile of the credit rating agency, or where a credit rating agency reports on behalf of a group in accordance with Article 1(4), the country of domicile of that credit rating agency, the deadline shall be the next working day.

  5. (5)

    Where no credit ratings or rating outlooks referred to in paragraph 1 were issued during the preceding calendar month, the credit rating agency shall not be obliged to submit any data.

Article 10 Reporting for the purpose of historical performance

The credit ratings issued or endorsed, or issued in a third country and not endorsed as referred to in Article 1(5), shall be used by the FCA for making available the historical performance data, in accordance with Article 11(2) of Regulation (EC) No 1060/2009 and point 1 of Part II of Section E of Annex I to that Regulation.

Article 11 Initial reporting

  1. (1)

    Credit rating agencies registered or certified on or before IP completion day shall prepare a first report to be reported to the FCA on IP completion day or on such later day as notified by the FCA, that shall contain information on all credit ratings and rating outlooks referred to in Articles 8 and 9, and that have been issued and not withdrawn IP completion day;

  2. (3)

    Credit rating agencies registered or certified after IP completion day shall comply with this Regulation within three months after the date of registration or certification. In their first report, they shall report, in accordance with Articles 8 and 9, all the credit ratings and rating outlooks that were issued from the date of registration or certification.

  3. (4)

    In addition to the first report referred to in paragraphs 2 and 3, a credit rating agency that is certified after IP completion day shall also report, pursuant to Article 11(2) of Regulation (EC) No 1060/2009 and point 1 of Part II of Section E of Annex I to that Regulation, its historical performance data relating to at least 10 years before the date of certification or, where it started its rating activity less than 10 years before the date of certification, relating to the period since it started its rating activity. Certified credit rating agencies shall not be required to report those data, partially or totally, where they can demonstrate that this would not be proportionate in view of their scale and complexity.

Article 12 Data structure

  1. (1)

    Credit rating agencies shall submit to the FCA qualitative data reports in the format specified in the tables in Part 1 of Annex I together with their first report of rating data in accordance with Article 11. Any changes to those qualitative data reports shall be immediately reported to the FCA’s system as an update, before the rating data which are affected by those changes are submitted to the FCA. Where a credit rating agency reports on behalf of a group, as referred to in Article 1(4), one set of qualitative data reports may be submitted to the FCA.

  2. (2)

    Credit rating agencies shall submit rating data reports for ratings referred to in Articles 8, 9 and 11 in the format specified in the tables in Part 2 of Annex I.

Article 13 Reporting procedures

  1. (1)

    Credit rating agencies shall submit the qualitative data reports and rating data reports referred to in Article 12 in accordance with the technical instructions provided by the FCA and using the FCA’s reporting system.

  2. (2)

    Credit rating agencies shall store the files sent to and received by the FCA in electronic form for at least five years. Those files shall be made available to the FCA on request.

  3. (3)

    Where a credit rating agency identifies factual errors in data that have been reported, it shall correct the relevant data without undue delay according to the technical instructions provided by the FCA.

Article 15 Entry into force

This Regulation shall enter into force on the twentieth day following that of its publication in the Official Journal of the European Union.

It shall apply from 21 June 2015.

Signature

Done at Brussels, 30 September 2014.

For the Commission

The President

José Manuel BARROSO

ANNEX I PART 1 LIST OF FIELDS FOR THE QUALITATIVE DATA FILE PART 2 LIST OF FIELDS FOR THE RATING DATA FILE

PART 1 LIST OF FIELDS FOR THE QUALITATIVE DATA FILE Table 1 CRA identification and methodology description

No

Field name

Description

Type

Standard

Scope

1

CRA identifier

Code used to identify the reporting credit rating agency. It is provided by the FCA upon registration or certification.

Mandatory.

Technical

2

Reporting CRA Global Legal Entity Identifier (LEI)

LEI code of the credit rating agency sending the file.

Mandatory.

ISO 17442

Public

3

CRA name

Name used to identify the credit rating agency. It shall correspond to the name used by the credit rating agency in the registration process and all other supervisory procedures within the FCA. Where one member of a group of credit rating agencies reports for the whole group it shall be the name referring to the group of credit rating agencies.

Mandatory.

Public

4

CRA Description

Brief description of the credit rating agency.

Mandatory.

Public

5

CRA Methodology

Description of the credit rating agency's rating methodology. The credit rating agency can describe unique features of its rating methodology.

Mandatory.

Public

6

Link to CRA website methodology page

The link to the credit rating agency's web page that contains all information related to the methodologies, and descriptions of models and key rating assumptions.

Mandatory.

Valid web page reference.

Public

7

Solicited and unsolicited ratings policies

Description of the credit rating agency's policy on solicited and unsolicited with or without participation ratings. If more than one policy exists, the relevant rating types applicable to each policy shall be specified.

Mandatory.

Public

8

Subsidiary ratings policy

Description of policy regarding the reporting of the rating of subsidiaries.

Mandatory.

Applicable for credit rating agencies issuing corporate ratings.

Public

9

Geographical reporting scope

In the case of a credit rating agency part of a group, they should mention whether they report all the ratings issued by the group (global scope) or not (only the UK and endorsed ratings). Where the coverage is not global, the credit rating agency shall explain why not. For all other CRAs it should be reported as "global" ("Y").

Mandatory.

Y — yes

N — no

Public

10

Reason for non-global scope

The reason why a credit rating agency which is part of a group, does not report all the ratings of the group.

Mandatory.

Applicable when "Geographical reporting scope" = "N"

Public

11

Definition of default

Describes the definition of default used by the credit rating agency.

Mandatory.

Public

12

Website link

Link to the home page of credit rating agency's public website.

Mandatory.

Valid web page reference.

Public
Table 2 Issuer rating types list

No

Field name

Description

Type

Standard

Scope

1

Issuer rating type identifier

Unique identifier for each issuer rating type that a rated entity can be assessed on.

Mandatory.

Applicable if the credit rating agency is issuing issuer ratings.

Technical

2

Issuer rating type name

Name of the issuer rating category.

Mandatory.

Technical

3

Issuer rating type description

Description of the rated debt category.

Mandatory.

Technical

4

Issuer rating type standard

This should distinguish the types of issuer ratings in: the main/global issuer credit rating, the debt rating type (the different categories will be described in Table 2, Part 2, Annex 1) and all other issuer debt ratings.

Mandatory.

IR — Main issuer rating

DT — Debt rating

OT — Other

Technical
Table 3 Debt categories list

No

Field name

Description

Type

Standard

Scope

1

Rated debt classification identifier

Unique identifier for each debt category used for classifying the corporate and sovereign issuer debt categories or debt issues.

Mandatory.

Applicable if the rating agency is rating corporate or sovereign debt categories

Technical

2

Rated debt classification name

Name of the rated debt category.

Mandatory.

Technical

3

Rated debt classification description

Description of the rated debt category.

Mandatory.

Technical

4

Seniority

Identifies the seniority of the debt class of the rated issuer or issue.

Optional.

SEU — in case the rated issuer debt or the issue belongs to the senior unsecured debt category

SEO — in case the rated issuer or the issue belongs to a senior debt category other than SEU

SB — in case the issuer debt or the issue belongs to a subordinated debt category.

Technical
Table 4 Issue/programme types list

No

Field name

Description

Type

Standard

Scope

1

Issue/programme type identifier

Unique identifier for each issue/programme used for classifying the issue ratings.

Mandatory.

Applicable if the credit rating agency is rating corporate or sovereign issues.

Technical

2

Issue/programme type name

Issue/programme name.

Mandatory.

Technical

3

Issue/programme type description

Issue/programme description.

Mandatory.

Technical
Table 5 Lead analysts list

This table shall contain a list of all the lead analysts that operate in the UK. If a lead analyst worked in different time periods as a lead analyst (with time gaps in between) then the lead analyst should be reported in the table multiple times: one for each lead analyst appointment period. The start and end date of allocation to the function shall not overlap for the same lead analyst. The table shall contain one line for each lead analyst and distinct function period.

No

Field name

Description

Type

Standard

Scope

1

Lead analyst internal identifier

Internal unique identifiers of the staff member who is appointed in the analyst function by the credit rating agency.

Mandatory.

Supervision only

2

Lead analyst name

Lead analyst full name.

Mandatory.

Supervision only

3

Lead analyst start date

The start date of the staff member in the lead analyst function.

Mandatory.

ISO 8601 date format (YYYY-MM-DD)

Supervision only

4

Lead analyst end date

The end date of the staff member in the lead analyst function If the staff member is currently working in the lead analyst function, it should be reported as 9999-01-01.

Mandatory.

ISO 8601 date format (YYYY-MM-DD) or 9999-01-01

Supervision only
Table 6 Rating scale

No

Field name

Description

Type

Standard

Scope

1

Rating scale identifier

Identifies uniquely a specific rating scale of the credit rating agency.

Mandatory.

Technical

2

Rating scale validity start date

The date at which the rating scale starts being valid.

Mandatory.

ISO 8601 date format (YYYY-MM-DD)

Public

3

Rating scale validity end date

The last date when a rating scale is valid. For the rating scale that re currently valid, it should be reported as 9999-01-01.

Mandatory.

ISO 8601 date format (YYYY-MM-DD) or 9999-01-01

Public

4

Description of the rating scale

Description of the type of ratings included in the scale, including the geographical scope where relevant.

Mandatory.

Public

5

Time horizon

Identifies the applicability of the rating scale based on the time horizon.

Mandatory.

L — where the rating scale is applicable to long-term ratings

S — where the rating scale is applicable to short-term ratings

Public

6

Rating type

Identifies the applicability of the rating scale based on the rating type.

Mandatory.

C — where the rating scale is applicable to corporate ratings

S — where the rating scale is applicable to sovereign & public finance ratings

T — where the rating scale is applicable to structured finance ratings

O — where the rating scale is applicable to other financial instruments

Public

7

Rating scale scope

Specifies if the rating scale is used for issuing preliminary ratings, final ratings or both.

Mandatory.

PR — rating scale is used for issuing preliminary ratings only

FR — rating scale is used for issuing final ratings only

BT — rating scale is used for issuing preliminary and final ratings

Public

8

Rating scale used for central repository

Indicates if the rating is to be used by the FCA for the central repository statistics calculations.

For any given period, only one rating scale per combination of rating type and time horizon can be used.

Mandatory.

Y — yes

N — no

Technical

9

Categories

Rating category value

Order of the rating category in the rating scale (where 1 is correspondent to the category that represents the best creditworthiness).

Mandatory.

The ordinal is an integer value with minimum value 1 and a maximum value of 20. The declaration of the rating categories values must be consecutive. There must be as a minimum one rating category for each rating.

Public

10

Rating category label

Identifies a specific rating category within the rating scale.

Mandatory.

Public

11

Rating category description

Definition of the rating category in the rating scale.

Mandatory.

Public

12

Notches

Notch value

Order of the notch in the rating scale (where 1 is correspondent to the notch that represents the best creditworthiness).

Mandatory.

The notch value is an integer with minimum value 1 and a maximum value of 99. Values provided must be consecutive. There must be as a minimum one rating notch for each rating.

Public

13

Notch label

Identifies a specific notch within the rating scale. Notches provide additional detail to the rating category.

Mandatory.

Public

14

Notch description

Description of the notch in the rating scale.

Mandatory.

Public

PART 2 LIST OF FIELDS FOR THE RATING DATA FILE Table 1 Data describing the rated entity/instrument

This table shall identify and describe all credit ratings issued by the credit rating agency and are to be reported for the scope of this Regulation. This table shall contain one line for each individual credit rating to be reported. Where it applies, for each credit rating line, one or more ‘Originators’ can be reported.

No

Field name

Description

Type

Standard

Scope

1

CRA identifier

Code used to identify the reporting credit rating agency. It is provided by the FCA upon registration or certification.

Mandatory.

Technical

2

Reporting CRA LEI

LEI code of the credit rating agency sending the file.

Mandatory.

ISO 17442

Public

3

Responsible CRA LEI

LEI code of the credit rating agency responsible for the rating, i.e. in case of:

a rating issued in the UK, the registered credit rating agency that has issued the rating,

Mandatory.

ISO 17442

Public

4

Issuer CRA LEI

LEI code of the credit rating agency that issued the rating, that is to say in case of:

a rating issued in the UK, the registered credit rating agency,

a rating issued by a certified credit rating agency, the certified entity,

a rating issued in a third country but not endorsed by a registered credit rating agency, the third country credit rating agency that issued the rating.

Mandatory.

ISO 17442

Public

5

Rating identifier

Unique identifier of the rating, which shall be maintained unchanged over time. The rating identifier shall be unique in all reports to the FCA.

Mandatory.

Technical

6

Rating type

Identifies whether the rating is a corporate rating, a sovereign or public finance rating, a structured finance rating or other financial instrument rating. It shall be maintained unchanged over time.

Mandatory.

C — if the rating is applicable to corporate ratings

S — if the rating is applicable to sovereign ratings

T — if the rating is applicable to structured finance ratings

O — if the rating is applicable to other financial instruments.

Public

7

Other rating type

Describes the type of rated financial instrument that was reported in the "O" rating type.

Mandatory.

Applicable for "Rating type" = "O".

Supervision only

8

Rated object

Specifies if the rating refers to an entity/issuer of debt or a debt issuance of a rated entity/financial instrument.

Mandatory.

ISR — the rating refers to an entity or issuer of debt

INT — the rating refers to a debt issuance/financial instrument.

Public

9

Time horizon

Identifies whether the rating is a short-term or a long-term rating. It shall be maintained unchanged over time.

Mandatory.

L — if the rating is a long-term rating

S — if the rating is a short-term rating.

Public

10

Country

Country code of the rated entity/instrument.

Mandatory.

ISO 3166-1 code.

The code "ZZ" shall be used to identify the category "international".

Public

11

Currency

Identifies whether the rating is expressed in respect of local or foreign currency.

Mandatory.

Applicable for "Rating type" = "C" or "S"

LC — in case of a local currency rating

FC — in case of a foreign currency rating.

Public

12

Legal entity/issuer LEI

LEI code of the legal entity/issuer. It shall be maintained unchanged over time.

Mandatory.

Applicable only if the rated entity is eligible for acquiring a LEI code.

ISO 17442

Public

13

Legal entity/issuer national fiscal code

Unique national fiscal code of the rated entity. It shall be maintained unchanged over time.

Optional.

If applicable.

Public

14

Legal entity/issuer value added tax (VAT) code

Unique national VAT code of the rated entity. It shall be maintained unchanged over time.

Optional.

If applicable.

Public

15

Legal entity/issuer Bank Identified Code (BIC)

Unique BIC of the rated entity. It shall be maintained unchanged over time.

Optional.

Applicable only for entities that represent financial institutions ("Industry" = "FI" or "IN").

ISO 9362

Public

16

Legal entity/issuer internal identifier

Unique internal identifier of the issuer. It shall be maintained unchanged over time.

Mandatory.

Supervision only

17

Legal entity/issuer name

It shall contain appropriate understandable reference to the legal name of the legal entity/issuer.

Mandatory.

Public

18

Parent legal entity/Issuer LEI

LEI code of the parent company. To be reported only in case the rated issuer is a subsidiary of another rated entity. It shall be maintained unchanged over time.

Mandatory.

Applicable if the rated entity/debt issuer is a subsidiary of another rated entity.

ISO 17442

Public

19

Parent legal entity/issuer internal identifier

Unique internal identifier of the parent entity/issuer. It shall be maintained unchanged over time.

Mandatory.

Applicable if the rated entity is a subsidiary of another rated entity.

Supervision only

20

Sub-sovereign Nomenclature of Territorial Units for Statistics (NUTS) code

Identifier of the city/region of the rated municipality/sub-sovereign.

Mandatory.

Applicable only for "Country" is part of the UK and for "Rating type" = "S" and "Sector" = "SM"

EUROSTAT nomenclature: NUTS 1 to 3

Public

21

ISIN

International Securities Identifying Number (ISIN) of the rated instrument. It shall be maintained unchanged over time.

Mandatory.

Applicable for "Rated object" = "INT" and if the rated instruments has an ISIN allocated.

ISO 6166

Public

[deleted]

23

Instrument internal identifier

Unique code to identify the financial instrument that is rated. It shall be maintained unchanged over time.

Mandatory.

Applicable for "Rated object" = "INT".

Supervision only

24

Issue/programme type

Indicates the issue/programme type of the rating.

Optional.

Applicable for "Rating type" = "C" or "S" and "Rated object" = "INT".

Valid "Issue/programme type identifier", previously reported in the "Issue/programme type list".

Public

25

Issuer rating type

Specifies the issuer rating type.

Mandatory.

Applicable for "Rating type" = "C" and for "Rated object" = "ISR"

Valid "Issuer rating type identifier", previously reported in the "Issuer rating type list".

Public

26

Debt category

Specifies the debt category for the rated issues or debts.

Mandatory.

Applicable for "Rating type" = "C" or "S" and "Rated object" = "ISR" and "Issuer rating type" = "DT" or "Rated object" = "INT" if applies.

Valid "Rated debt classification identifier", previously reported in the "Debt categories list".

Public

27

Issuance date

Specifies the issuance date of the rated instrument or debt issuance. It shall be maintained unchanged over time.

Mandatory.

Applicable for "Rated object" = "INT".

ISO 8601 date format: (YYYY-MM-DD)

Supervision only

28

Maturity date

The maturity date of the rated instrument or debt issuance.

Mandatory.

Applicable for "Rated object" = "INT".

If perpetual: 9999-01-01.

ISO 8601 date format: (YYYY-MM-DD) or 9999-01-01

Supervision only

29

Outstanding issue volume

The outstanding issue volume at first rating issuance. The amount shall be reported in the currency of the issuance reported in "Outstanding issue volume currency code".

Mandatory.

Applicable for "Rated object" = "INT".

Supervision only

30

Outstanding issue volume currency code

The code of the currency of the rated issue.

Mandatory.

Applicable for "Rated object" = "INT".

ISO 4217

Supervision only

31

Industry

Categorisation of the rated entity or debt issuances reported under the "corporate" rating type in financial, insurance and non-financial corporates.

Mandatory.

Applicable for "Rating type" = "C".

FI — for financial institution rating including banks, brokers and dealers

IN — for insurance institution rating

CO — for corporate institution rating that is not included in "FI" or "IN"

Public

32

Sector

Specifies subcategories for sovereign and public finance ratings.

Mandatory.

Applicable for "Rating type" = "S".

SV — for State rating

SM — for regional or local authority ratingIF — for international financial institution rating

SO — for supranational organisations rating other than "IF"

PE — for public entities rating.

Public

33

Asset class

Defines the main asset classes for structured finance ratings.

Mandatory.

Applicable for "Rating type" = "T".

ABS — for ABS rating

RMBS — for RMBS rating

CMBS — for CMBS rating

CDO — for CDO rating

ABCP — for ABCP rating

OTH — for other.

Public

34

Sub-asset

Defines the sub-asset classes for the structured finance ratings.

Mandatory.

Applicable for "Rating type" = "T".

CCS — if ABS: credit card receivable backed securities

ALB — if ABS: auto loan backed securities

CNS — if ABS: consumer loan backed security

SME — if ABS: small and medium-sized enterprises loan backed securities

LES — if ABS: leases to individual or business backed security

HEL — if RMBS: home equity loans

PRR — if RMBS: prime RMBS, NPR — if RMBS: non-prime RMBS

CFH — if CDO: cash flow and hybrid CDOs/CLOs

SDO — if CDO: synthetic CDOs/CLOs

MVO — if CDO: market value CDOs

SIV — if OTH: structured investment vehicles

ILS — if OTH: insurance-linked securities

DPC — if OTH: derivative product companies

SCB — if OTH: structured covered bonds

OTH — other.

Public

35

Other sub-asset class

Indicates the other asset or sub-asset class category.

Mandatory.

Applicable for "Rating-type" = "T" and "Sub-asset" = "OTH".

Supervision only

36

Corporate issues classifications

Classification of covered bonds.

Mandatory.

Applicable for "Rating type" = "C" and "Rated object" = "INT".

BND — bonds

CBR — CRR covered bonds as defined in point 128A of Article 4(1) of Regulation (EU) No 575/2013 that meet the eligibility requirements set out in Article 129 of that Regulation

OCB — other types of covered bonds, for which the credit rating agency has used specific covered bonds methodologies, models or key rating assumptions for issuing the credit rating and which are not included in point (b) of Article 5(2) of this Regulation

OTH — other types of corporate issues which are not included in points (a), (b) and (c) of Article 5(2) of this Regulation..

Public

37

Other corporate issues

Describes the type of issue reported under the "other" category of corporate issues.

Mandatory.

Applicable for "Corporate issues classifications" = "OTH".

Supervision only

38

Tranche class

Class of the tranche.

Mandatory.

Applicable for "Rating type" = "T".

Public

39

Series No/programme ID

In case the issue is part of a series of multiple issuances under the same programme, it shall specify the issue's specific series number. Programme ID could be added, where this exists, to complement the "Programme/deal/issuance name".

Optional.

Applicable for "Rating type" = "T" or 'Rating type = "C" and "Rated object" = "INT".

Public

40

Programme/deal/issuance name

Specifies the programme/deal/issuance name used in the public issuance documents

Optional.

Applicable for "Rated object" = "INT".

Public

41

Originators

Originator internal identifier

Unique internal code assigned by the credit rating agency to the originator.

Mandatory.

Applicable for "Rating type" = "T".

In case of multiple originators that cannot be individually identified, "MULTIPLE" should be reported.

Supervision only

42

Originator LEI

LEI code of the originator.

Mandatory.

Applicable for "Rating type" = "T" and "Originator Internal Identifier " is not "MULTIPLE".

ISO 17442

Supervision only

43

Originator BIC code

Unique BIC of the originator.

Optional.

Applicable for "Rating type" = "T" and "Originator Internal Identifier " is not "MULTIPLE".

ISO 9362

Supervision only

44

Originator name

It shall contain appropriate understandable reference to the legal name of the originator (or the parent company of the issuer).

Mandatory.

Applicable for "Rating type" = "T" and "Originator internal identifier " is not "MULTIPLE".

Supervision only

45

Preceding preliminary rating

For all the new ratings it specifies if the credit rating agency issued a preliminary rating or initial review before issuing the final rating.

Mandatory.

Applicable for "Action type" = "NEW" in Table 2 of Part 2

Y — yes

N — no

Supervision only

46

Preceding preliminary rating identifier

Indicates the rating identifier of the preceding issued preliminary rating or initial review. The "Preceding preliminary rating identifier" should correspond to an already reported valid preliminary rating "Rating identifier".

Mandatory.

Applicable for "Preceding preliminary rating" = "Y"

Supervision only

47

Complexity indicator

Indicates the complexity grade assigned to a structured finance rating considering factors such as the number of originators, counterparties, countries, the need to develop new methodologies or new innovative features, credit enhancements, underlying documentation, complex collateral, different or new jurisdictions and/or existence of derivative components amongst other factors that may be considered relevant by the CRA when it is assessing the complexity of a rating service.

Mandatory.

Applicable for "Rating type" = "T".

S — standard complexity

C —additional complexity

Supervision only

48

Structured finance transaction type

Indication of whether the instrument refers to a stand-alone or master-trust.

Mandatory.

Applicable for "Rating type" = "T".

S — stand-alone transaction

M — master trust transaction

Supervision only

49

Type of rating for the public rating database

Identifies the credit ratings that fall under the scope of the public rating database, based on the requirements set out in Article 11a of the Regulation (EC) No 1060/2009.

Mandatory.

NXI — the rating is not exclusively produced for and disclosed to investors for a fee

EXI — the rating is exclusively produced for and disclosed to investors for a fee

Technical

50

Relevant for central repository statistics calculation

Indicates if the rating shall be used for central repository statistics calculation.

Mandatory.

Y — yes

N — no

Technical
Table 2 Data about the individual credit rating actions

This table contains all the rating actions that are issued in relation to the credit ratings reported in Table 1. Where the press releases or the sovereign research reports are issued in multiple languages, multiple versions of the press releases or the sovereign research reports can be reported for the same rating action.

No

Field name

Description

Type

Standard

Scope

1

Rating action identifier

Unique identifier of the rating action. Rating action identifier shall be unique per each reported rating.

Mandatory.

Technical

2

Rating identifier

Unique identifier of the rating.

Mandatory.

Should be a valid "Rating identifier" reported in Table 1 of Part 2

Technical

3

Action validity date and time

The date and time of validity of the action. This shall coincide with the Coordinated Universal Time (UTC) of publication of the action or distribution by subscription.

Mandatory.

ISO 8601 extended date time format: YYYY-MM-DD (HH:MM:SS)

Public

4

Action communication date and time

The date and time of communication of the action to the rated entity.

It shall be expressed as Coordinated Universal Time (UTC). Should be reported only for the ratings issued in the UK.

Mandatory.

Applicable for "Location of the rating issuance " = "I".

ISO 8601 extended date time format: YYYY-MM-DD (HH:MM:SS)

Supervision only

5

Action decision date

Identifies the date when the action is decided.

It shall be the date of preliminary approval (such as by the rating committee) of the action where this is then communicated to the rated entity before final approval.

Should be reported only for the ratings issued in the UK.

Mandatory.

Applicable for "Location of the rating issuance " = "I".

ISO 8601 date format: (YYYY-MM-DD)

Supervision only

6

Action type

Identifies the type of action carried out by the credit rating agency with respect to a specific rating.

Mandatory.

OR — in case of outstanding rating (only for first time reporting)

PR — in case of preliminary rating

NW — in case the rating is issued for the first time

UP — in case the rating is upgraded

DG — in case the rating is downgraded

AF — in case the rating is affirmed

DF — in case a rated issuer or instrument is assigned to or removed from a default status and the default is not linked with another rating action

SP — in case the rating is suspended

WD — in case the rating is withdrawn

OT — in case the rating is placed to or removed from the outlook/trend status

WR — in case the rating is placed to or removed from the watch/review status

Public

7

Outlook/watch/default status

An outlook/watch/suspension/default status is assigned, kept or removed with respect to the rating,

Mandatory.

Applicable for "Action type" = "OT","WR", "DF", "SP" or "OR"

P — status is placed

M — status is maintained

R — status is removed

Public

8

Outlook

Identifies the outlook/trend assigned to a rating by the CRA according to its relevant policy.

Mandatory.

Applicable for "Action type" = "OT" and "OR"

POS — in case of a positive outlook

NEG — in case of a negative outlook

EVO — in case of an evolving or developing outlook

STA — in case of a stable outlook

Public

9

Watch/Review

Identifies the watch or review status assigned to a rating by the CRA according to its relevant policy.

Mandatory.

Applicable for "Action type" = "WR" and "OR"

POW — in case of a positive watch/review

NEW — in case of a negative watch/review

EVW — in case of an evolving or developing watch/review

UNW — in case of a watch/review with uncertain direction

Public

10

Watch/Review determinant

Identifies the reason for the watch/review status of a rating. Should be reported only for the ratings issued in the UK.

Mandatory.

Applicable for "Action type" = "WR" and "OR" and "Location of the rating issuance " = "I".

1 — where the watch/review status is due to changes in methodologies, models or key rating assumptions

2 — where the watch/review status is due to economic, financial or credit reasons

3 — where the watch or review status is due to other reasons (e.g. departure of analysts, occurrence of conflicts of interests)

Public

11

Withdrawal reason

Identifies the reason of a withdrawal action.

Mandatory.

Applicable for "Action Type" = "WD"

1 — in case of incorrect or insufficient information on issuer/issue

2 — in case of bankruptcy of the rated entity or debt restructuring

3 — in case of reorganisation of rated entity (including the merger or acquisition of the rated entity)

4 — in case of the end of maturity of the debt obligation, or in case the debt is redeemed, called, prefunded, cancelled

5 — in case of automatic invalidity of rating due to business model of CRA (such as expiry of ratings valid for a predetermined period)

6 — in case of rating withdrawal due to other reasons

7 — in case the rating is affected by one of the points specified in Annex I, Section B, Point 3 of the Regulation (EC) No 1060/2009

8 — in case of client's request

Public

12

Other withdrawal reason

Where the rating was withdrawn due to other reasons than the ones provided, please specify the reason

Mandatory.

Applicable for "Withdrawal reason" = 6

Supervision only

13

Default flag

Where the rated entity or the financial instrument is defaulted or removed from default as a result of another rating action (i.e.: upgrade, downgrade)

Mandatory.

Applicable for "Action type" = "AF", "DG", "UP" or "OR"

Y — yes

N — no

Public

14

Suspension reason

Specifies the reason for a suspension action.

Mandatory.

Applicable for "Action type" = "SP"

Public

15

Rating scale identifier

Identifies the rating scale used for issuing the rating action.

Mandatory.

Applicable for "Action type" = "NW" or "UP" or "AF" or "DG" or "PR" or "OR"

Valid "Rating scale identifier", previously reported in the "Rating scale" table.

Public

16

Rating value

Notch value assigned by the credit rating agency as a result of the rating action.

Mandatory.

Applicable for "Action type" = "NW" or "UP" or "AF" or "DG" or "PR" or "OR"

Valid "Notch value", previously reported in the "Rating scale" table.

Public

17

Location of the rating issuance

Specifies the location of the issuance of the credit ratings by: ratings issued in the UK by a registered credit rating agency, ratings issued by third country credit rating agency belonging to the same group of credit rating agencies and endorsed in the UK, ratings issued by certified credit rating agencies or ratings issued by third country credit rating agency belonging to the same group of credit rating agencies but not endorsed in the UK.

Mandatory.

I — issued in the UK

E — endorsed

T — issued in a third country by a certified CRA

O — other (not endorsed)

N — not available (only valid before 1.1.2011).

Public

18

Lead analyst identifier

Unique identifier of the lead analyst responsible for the rating. Should be reported only for the ratings issued in the UK.

Mandatory.

Applicable for "Location of the rating issuance " = "I".

Valid "Lead analyst internal identifier", previously reported in the "Lead analysts list".

Supervision only

19

Country of the lead analyst

Identifies the country of the office where the responsible lead analyst was located when issuing the rating.

Mandatory.

Applicable for "Location of the rating issuance " = "I".

ISO 3166-1 code.

Supervision only

20

Solicitation status

Solicitation status of the rated entity/instrument.

Mandatory.

S — if the rating is solicited,

U — if the rating is unsolicited without participation

P — if the rating is unsolicited with participation.

Public

21

Press release

Press release

Specifies if the rating action was accompanied by a press release.

Mandatory.

Applicable for "Type of rating for ERP" = "NXI".

Y — yes

N — no.

Public

22

Press release language

Indicates the language in which the press release was issued.

Mandatory.

Applicable for "Press release" = "Y".

ISO 639-1

Public

23

Press release file name

Indicates the file name under which the press release was reported.

Mandatory.

Applicable for "Press release" = "Y".

FCA standard

Public

24

Link to press release

Where the rating action is accompanied by the same press release as another rating action, it should state the "Action identifier" for the action for which the common press release was firstly submitted.

Mandatory.

Applicable for press releases that relate to more than one rating action.

Valid "Action identifier"

Technical

25

Research report

Research report

Specifies if the rating action was accompanied by a research report. Applicable only for sovereign ratings reported under the sector: "SV" or "SM" or "IF"

Mandatory.

Applicable for "Rating type" = "S" and "Sector" = "SV" or "SM" or "IF"

Y — yes

N — no

Public

26

Research report language

Indicates the language under which the research report was issued.

Mandatory.

Applicable for "Sovereign Research Report" = "Y"

ISO 639-1

Public

27

Research report file name

Indicates the file name under which the research report was reported.

Mandatory.

Applicable for "Sovereign Research Report" = "Y"

FCA standard

Public

28

Link to research report

Where the rating is accompanied by the same research report as another rating action, it should state the "Action identifier" for the action for which the common research report was firstly submitted.

Optional.

Valid "Action identifier"

Technical

ANNEX II Correlation table

Correlation table

This Regulation

Regulation (EU) No 446/2012

Regulation (EU) No 448/2012

Article 1(1)

Article 3(1)

Article 1(2)

Article 2(1)

Article 2(2)

Article 1(3)

Article 2(6)

Article 1(4)

Article 2(2)

Article 2(3)

Article 1(5)

Article 3(3)

Article 1(6)

Article 3(2)

Article 2(1)

Article 8(2)

Article 2(2)

Article 8(3)

Article 3

Article 4(1)

Article 3(5)

Article 4

Article 4(3)

Article 4

Article 5

Article 4(2)

Article 5

Article 6

Article 6

Article 7

Article 8

Article 9(1)

Article 3(2)

Article 9(2)

Article 2(3)

Article 9(3)

Article 2(4)

Article 9(4)

Article 2(5)

Article 9(5)

Article 3(3)

Article 10

Article 11(1) to (3)

Article 11(4)

Article 3(4)

Article 12

Article 3(1) and (4)

Article 2(1) and Article 7 and Article 8(1)

Article 13

Article 5

Article 9, Article 10, Article 11, Article 12 and Article 13

Article 14

Article 15

Article 6

Article 14