Content Options:

Content Options

View Options:


You are viewing the version of the document as on 2022-12-13.

COMP 12.4 The compensation calculation

Protected investment business: general

COMP 12.4.2R

The FSCS may pay compensation for any claim made in connection with protected investment business which is not:

  1. (1)

    a claim for property held; or

  2. (2)

    a claim arising from transactions which remain uncompleted at the quantification date;

only to the extent that the FSCS considers that the payment of compensation is essential in order to provide the claimant with fair compensation.

COMP 12.4.3R

The FSCS must not pay compensation for any claim in connection with protected investment business to the extent that it relates to or depends on:

  1. (1)

    a failure of investment performance to match a guarantee given or representation made; or

  2. (2)

    a contractual obligation to pay or promise to pay which the FSCS considers to have been undertaken without full consideration passing to the relevant person or in anticipation of possible insolvency; or

  3. (3)

    the mere fluctuation in the value of an investment.

COMP 12.4.4R

If the claimant has an ICD claim against a pre-IP completion day incoming EEA firm12 which is a MiFID investment firm59 or, where applicable, a successor of such a firm8, and the act or omission giving rise to the ICD claim arose before exit day,11 the FSCS must take account of the liability of the EEA State compensation scheme11 in calculating the compensation payable by the FSCS. For the purposes of applying this rule, “ICD claim” and “MiFID investment firm” have the meaning they had immediately before exit day.11

85855

Protected investment business: claims covered by the pensions review

COMP 12.4.5R

If the claimant has a claim in connection with protected investment business relating to the fact that the claimant has:

  1. (1)

    while eligible or reasonably likely to become eligible to be a member of an occupational pension scheme, instead become a member of a personal pension scheme or entered into a retirement annuity; or

  2. (2)

    ceased to be a member of, or to pay contributions to, an occupational pension scheme, and has instead become a member of a personal pension scheme or entered into a retirement annuity; or

  3. (3)

    transferred to a personal pension scheme accrued rights under an occupational pension scheme which is not a defined contribution (money purchase) scheme; or

  4. (4)

    ceased to be a member of an occupational pension scheme and has instead (by virtue of such a provision as is mentioned in section 591(2)(g) of the Income and Corporation Taxes Act 1988) entered into arrangements for securing relevant benefits by means of an annuity;

the FSCS must take the steps set out in COMP 12.4.6R.

COMP 12.4.6R

If COMP 12.4.5R applies, the FSCS must follow the Specification of Standards and Procedures issued by the FSA in October 1994, as supplemented and modified by subsequent guidance issued by the FSA (in particular, that of November 1996) (the 'Specification') in:

  1. (1)

    assessing whether a relevant person has complied with the relevant regulatory requirements;

  2. (2)

    assessing whether non-compliance has caused the claimant loss; and

  3. (3)

    calculating the amount of compensation due (where the FSCS may rely on calculations made by the FCA or any previous regulator of the relevant person);

unless the FSCS considers that departure from the Specification is essential in order to provide the claimant with fair compensation.

Protected investment business: FSAVC Review

COMP 12.4.7R

Where a claim made in connection with protected investment business relates to an Additional Voluntary Contribution policy advised on or arranged by a relevant person, the FSCS must follow the FSAVC Review Model Guidance issued by the FSA in May 2000 (the "Guidance") in:

  1. (1)

    assessing whether the relevant person has complied with the relevant regulatory requirements;

  2. (2)

    assessing whether non-compliance has caused the claimant loss; and

  3. (3)

    calculating the compensation due (where the FSCS may rely on calculations made by the FCA or any previous regulator of the relevant person);

unless the FSCS considers that departure from the Guidance is essential in order to provide the claimant with fair compensation.

Protected investment business: excessive benefits

COMP 12.4.8R

The FSCS may decide to reduce the compensation that would otherwise be payable for a claim made in connection with protected investment business that is not an ICD claim, if it is satisfied that:

  1. (1)

    there is evidence of contributory negligence by the claimant; or

  2. (2)

    payment of the full amount would provide a greater benefit than the claimant might reasonably have expected or than the benefit available on similar investments with other relevant persons; and

it would be inequitable for the FSCS not to take account of (1) or (2).

37
COMP 12.4.16R

[deleted]9

3

4Protected home finance mediation41

COMP 12.4.17R

31The FSCS may pay compensation for any claim made in connection with protected home finance mediation 4only to the extent that the FSCS considers that the payment of compensation is essential in order to provide the claimant with fair compensation.

4
COMP 12.4.18R

31The FSCS must not pay compensation for any claim in connection with protected home finance mediation 4to the extent that it relates or depends on:

4
  1. (1)

    a failure of investment performance to match a guarantee given or representation made; or

  2. (2)

    the mere fluctuation in the value of property

COMP 12.4.19R

1The FSCS may decide to reduce the compensation that would otherwise be payable for a claim made in connection with protected home finance mediation4 if it is satisfied that there is evidence of contributory negligence by the claimant and it would be inequitable for FSCS not to take account of that fact.

4

3Protected non-investment insurance distribution

COMP 12.4.20R

3The FSCS may pay compensation for any claim made in connection with protected non-investment insurance distribution10 only to the extent that the FSCS considers that the payment of compensation is essential in order to provide the claimant with fair compensation.

COMP 12.4.21R

3The FSCS may decide to reduce the compensation that would otherwise be payable for a claim made in connection with protected non-investment insurance distribution10 if it is satisfied that:

  1. (1)

    there is evidence of contributory negligence by the claimant; or

  2. (2)

    payment of the full amount would provide a greater benefit than the claimant might reasonably have expected or than the benefit available on similar contracts with other relevant persons; and

it would be inequitable for FSCS not to take account of (1) or (2).

Protected debt management business

COMP 12.4.21AR

9The FSCS may pay compensation for any claim made in connection with protected debt management business only to the extent that the FSCS considers that the payment of compensation is essential to provide the claimant with fair compensation.

Protected funeral plan business

COMP 12.4.21BR

13The FSCS may pay compensation for any claim made in connection with protected funeral plan business only to the extent that the FSCS considers that the payment of compensation is essential to provide the claimant with fair compensation.

Consumer redress schemes

COMP 12.4.22R

6For a claim which falls to be dealt with (or has properly been dealt with) under a consumer redress scheme, the FSCS must apply the scheme in:

  1. (1)

    assessing whether a relevant person has complied with the relevant regulatory requirements;

  2. (2)

    assessing whether non-compliance has caused the claimant loss; and

  3. (3)

    calculating the compensation due (where the FSCS may rely on calculations made by the FCA or other competent persons acting on the FCA's behalf or authorised to make them under the scheme);

    unless the FSCS considers that departure from the scheme is essential in order to provide the claimant with fair compensation.